Ashes to ashes?
Sep. 4th, 2005 08:55 amI wish the call up of Collingwood and Anderson warmed my split Lancashire/Durham heart more than it does. I can see the logic of dropping Tremlett. He's out of form and not obviously a replacement for Jones. After all, if Freddy and Harmison can't bounce the convicts out, it's not very likely that Tremlett will. Anderson is the same kind of bowler as Jones. On his day he can reverse it but, as I know only too well, his form hasn't been sparkling. 51 wickets at 31.8 in division 2 of the championship is a bit less than awe inspiring. Mind you, listening to the pundits at Lords yesterday talk about recalling Gough or Caddick or even Dominic Cork, makes one realise that this was a pretty tough decision for the selectors. I guess one just has to face the fact that England have three and a half test class seamers and almost a spinner when everyone is fit. It's all rather thin and at least this time no-one can claim they are not available because they are all in Iraq.
So what to do if Jones doesn't emerge from his oxygen chamber or whatever the team witch doctors have him in? I'd play Collingwood. It's the negative option. It makes it less likely that England can bowl out the convicts twice but it also materially diminishes the chance that they can do England twice. And this time a draw is enough.
Plus, the 200th anniversary of Trafalgar approaches and no Nelson has ever played for England (though two first class cricketers of that name were killed in action in the world wars) so a Collingwood will have to do. After all, one made a pretty good last minute replacement on that bloody day.
So what to do if Jones doesn't emerge from his oxygen chamber or whatever the team witch doctors have him in? I'd play Collingwood. It's the negative option. It makes it less likely that England can bowl out the convicts twice but it also materially diminishes the chance that they can do England twice. And this time a draw is enough.
Plus, the 200th anniversary of Trafalgar approaches and no Nelson has ever played for England (though two first class cricketers of that name were killed in action in the world wars) so a Collingwood will have to do. After all, one made a pretty good last minute replacement on that bloody day.