La Sonnambula
Mar. 21st, 2009 05:11 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
chickenfeetToday's MetHD broadcast was Bellini's La Sonnambula. This is a new and rather controversial production by Mary Zimmerman. By and large it's had a mixed reception from critics and audience both. The plot is pretty slim. There is an engaged couple in an alpine village. The female half of which (Armina) sleepwalks herself compromisingly into the bed of a count who is staying at the local inn. It being opera she is then rejected angrily by her betrothed but, since this is a comedy, she doesn't go mad, stab people and die after singing about it at great length. Instead all is cleared up by the kindly count and everyone lives happily ever after. It's pretty slight. In an attempt to make a bit more out of it Zimmerman does the play within a play thing setting the work in a rehearsal space in New York City with the various relationships in the opera proper being parallelled in the cast. It sort of works for the first scene which is just really about flirting and jealousy although what the Count is supposed to be in relation to the rehearsing opera company is a bit weird. It gets weirder in the second scene where the Count is apparently dossing in the rehearsal space. Presumably this is because there are no hotels in New York. Somehow Armina manages to sleepwalk into the rehearsal space. Nobody seems to find it odd that someone would walk barefoot in a nightdress across Manhattan (in winter) without getting molested. It just gets messier from there culminating in a slapstick finale with the cast now in full costume as jolly alpine peasants running through some truly over the top choreography. So no, Pinter could get away with this kind of plot device but he showed a bit more restraint.
Fortunately the performances were really very good indeed. Natalie Dessay as Armina displayed all her very considerable talents as a comedienne and without them it really would have been dismal. Michele Pertusi was a wonderful Count Rodolfo. He sang splendidly and had a gift for comic timing not far short of Dessay. He also looked every inch the aristocrat. Juan Domingo Florez played Juan Domingo Florez with his usual athleticism and amazing vocal range and power. He really is the definitive romantic tenor. I also really liked Jennifer Black's sly Lisa. Other parts, chorus and orchestra were more than acceptable. So, a flawed production but enjoyable if one didn't stop to think too much about the plot flaws.
I'm really not convinced by Mary Zimmerman as an opera director. She's trying too hard. The false cleverness in La Sonnambula didn't work and her Lucia was made even sillier than usual by moving the setting to the late 19th century. Much of what went on this afternoon was about as plausible as the idea that a country house party in the Lothians in the 1870s could feature vendetta, murder, forced marriage and the threat of beheading for treason.
Fortunately the performances were really very good indeed. Natalie Dessay as Armina displayed all her very considerable talents as a comedienne and without them it really would have been dismal. Michele Pertusi was a wonderful Count Rodolfo. He sang splendidly and had a gift for comic timing not far short of Dessay. He also looked every inch the aristocrat. Juan Domingo Florez played Juan Domingo Florez with his usual athleticism and amazing vocal range and power. He really is the definitive romantic tenor. I also really liked Jennifer Black's sly Lisa. Other parts, chorus and orchestra were more than acceptable. So, a flawed production but enjoyable if one didn't stop to think too much about the plot flaws.
I'm really not convinced by Mary Zimmerman as an opera director. She's trying too hard. The false cleverness in La Sonnambula didn't work and her Lucia was made even sillier than usual by moving the setting to the late 19th century. Much of what went on this afternoon was about as plausible as the idea that a country house party in the Lothians in the 1870s could feature vendetta, murder, forced marriage and the threat of beheading for treason.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-03-21 09:30 pm (UTC)1) Did you guys miss the audio on Debbie Voigt's entire introductory speech?
2) Were the color balance and contrast on your screening all wrong, or was it like normal? I was at a different theater this week, and it was completely fucked up.
no subject
Date: 2009-03-21 10:14 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-03-22 05:29 pm (UTC)I still think that this works better than the traditonal opera, but it gets kind of messy, doing it with this plot device of the rehersal. Still, I enjoyed myself and after four hours of Lucia I was happy to get out at 4 pm for a change.
no subject
Date: 2009-03-24 05:44 pm (UTC)Ha!